More educated, more WEIRD: Higher education predicts worldwide cultural similarity to the United States and other WEIRD countries
[NOT READ. PREPRINT, NOT PEER REVIEWED. Located as a reference in Schimmelpfennig and colleagues 2024 and in Petrutiu and colleagues 2026, both of which cite it for the claim that higher formal education predicts cultural similarity to the United States and other WEIRD countries] White, C., & Muthukrishna, M. (2023). 'More educated, more WEIRD: Higher education predicts worldwide cultural similarity to the United States and other WEIRD countries.' PsyArXiv. doi:10.31234/osf.io/8wr5d. IF IT HOLDS, IT IS THE DEEPEST POINT IN THE FILE: recruiting a university sample in Delhi or Sao Paulo does not escape the problem, it reproduces it, because the variable doing the work is education and education is what a university sample selects on. That is also Henrich's own Prelude argument in different clothes, where neuroscientists testing East Asian students at American universities would have confirmed their prior result, since university students are, by selection, highly literate. THE CLAIM MUST BE ATTRIBUTED TO THE TWO PUBLISHED PAPERS THAT CITE IT, LABELLED AS A PREPRINT, AND NOT QUOTED.
[NOT READ. PREPRINT, NOT PEER REVIEWED. Located as a reference in Schimmelpfennig and colleagues 2024 and in Petrutiu and colleagues 2026, both of which cite it for the claim that higher formal education predicts cultural similarity to the United States and other WEIRD countries] White, C., & Muthukrishna, M. (2023). 'More educated, more WEIRD: Higher education predicts worldwide cultural similarity to the United States and other WEIRD countries.' PsyArXiv. doi:10.31234/osf.io/8wr5d. IF IT HOLDS, IT IS THE DEEPEST POINT IN THE FILE: recruiting a university sample in Delhi or Sao Paulo does not escape the problem, it reproduces it, because the variable doing the work is education and education is what a university sample selects on. That is also Henrich's own Prelude argument in different clothes, where neuroscientists testing East Asian students at American universities would have confirmed their prior result, since university students are, by selection, highly literate. THE CLAIM MUST BE ATTRIBUTED TO THE TWO PUBLISHED PAPERS THAT CITE IT, LABELLED AS A PREPRINT, AND NOT QUOTED.
Written from the nOT READ. PREPRINT, NOT PEER REVIEWED. Located as a reference in Schimmelpfennig and colleagues 2024 and in Petrutiu and colleagues 2026, both of which cite it for the claim that higher formal education predicts cultural similarity to the United States and other WEIRD countries.
What our sources record
Recorded when this source was checked, figures included, with page references and quotation marks removed.
White, C., & Muthukrishna, M. (2023). More educated, more WEIRD: Higher education predicts worldwide cultural similarity to the United States and other WEIRD countries. PsyArXiv. doi:10.31234/osf.io/8wr5d